Skip to main content
Totu Legal

U.S. business

In-House Lawyer or Outsourced Legal Team? What a Company Should Weigh

Should your company hire an in-house lawyer or use an outsourced legal team? What drives the cost of each, how workload and expertise breadth matter, and what changes when you operate in Poland and the U.S.

6 min read

Key takeaways

  • An in-house lawyer makes sense when there is enough steady legal work to fill a full-time role in one area of law.
  • An outsourced legal team, or fractional general counsel, fits companies whose legal needs are regular but not full-time, or span several areas.
  • The cost of an in-house lawyer goes well beyond salary; the cost of outside counsel depends on hours and on how much context the lawyer already has.
  • Companies in Poland and the U.S. need advice on two legal systems, which one in-house hire rarely covers alone.
  • Many companies combine both. In-house counsel handles daily matters, and outside counsel covers other jurisdictions and specialist work.

A company should hire an in-house lawyer when it has enough steady legal work in one main area to fill a full-time role. An outsourced legal team, sometimes called an outsourced legal department or fractional general counsel, usually fits better when legal needs are regular but not full-time, span several areas of law, or cover more than one country, such as Poland and the U.S.

This article walks through what drives the cost of each option, how workload and breadth of expertise affect the choice, and how to keep continuity either way. To put your own scenario into numbers, use the legal cost calculator.

What does an in-house lawyer actually do?

An in-house lawyer is an employee of the company who handles its legal work from the inside, close to management and the business.

Typical responsibilities include reviewing and negotiating contracts, advising management and HR, keeping corporate records in order, managing compliance and coordinating outside law firms when specialist work is needed.

The main strengths of an in-house lawyer:

  • Deep knowledge of the business. They know the products, the people and the history of past deals.
  • Availability. They sit in meetings and can answer quickly.
  • Early involvement. They see issues before they become legal problems.

The main limits:

  • One person, one background. Most lawyers specialize. One hire rarely covers commercial contracts, employment, tax, immigration and corporate law in two countries.
  • Licensing. A lawyer's license is tied to a jurisdiction. Someone qualified in Poland is not, on that basis, qualified to advise on U.S. law, and the reverse is also true.
  • Outside counsel is still needed. Disputes, transactions and specialist questions often go to a law firm anyway.

An outsourced legal team is an outside law firm or attorney that works as your company's legal function on an ongoing basis, rather than being hired for one matter at a time.

In practice, your team writes to the same lawyer or lawyers with every question, as it would to an in-house colleague. The firm keeps your documents and history, so the context builds up over time.

With Totu Legal business legal plans, that looks like this:

  • A set number of attorney hours each month: 6 on Basic, 15 on Pro, 30 on Enterprise.
  • Agreed reply times: within 2 business days on Basic, 1 business day on Pro and the same business day on Enterprise.
  • Business, corporate, employment and immigration advice in Poland and the U.S., with Polish & U.S. Tax Advisory on Pro and Enterprise.
  • A client portal where you see your matters, documents and hours used, and the Totu Legal AI assistant for questions about your matters and documents.
  • On Enterprise, a dedicated attorney for your company and a monthly report of the work done and hours used.

For a deeper look at this model, see outsourced legal department.

What drives the cost of an in-house lawyer?

The cost of an in-house lawyer is driven by much more than salary, and most of it is fixed whether or not there is legal work that month.

We don't quote salary figures here, because they vary widely by country, city, seniority and specialization. Instead, list the cost items that apply to your company:

  • Salary and bonus, set by seniority and the local market.
  • Employer costs, such as social security contributions, benefits and payroll taxes, which differ between Poland and the U.S.
  • Recruitment, including the time it takes to find the right person.
  • Tools and resources, such as legal databases, software, training and professional fees.
  • Management time, because someone has to supervise and review the role.
  • Outside counsel on top, for areas and jurisdictions the in-house lawyer does not cover.
  • Vacancy risk. If the lawyer leaves, the work stops until a replacement starts.

The cost of outside counsel is driven mainly by how many hours your company uses and how much the lawyer already knows about your business.

The main factors:

  • Monthly volume of contracts, questions, hires and filings.
  • Scope. Which areas of law and which jurisdictions are covered.
  • Billing model. Hourly billing, a retainer or a subscription. Our comparison of retainers, subscriptions and hourly billing explains the differences.
  • Context. A firm that handles your company every month spends less time getting up to speed than one hired matter by matter.
  • Work quoted separately. Large one-off matters, such as disputes or full immigration cases, are often priced on their own.

The legal cost calculator puts a plan, hourly billing and an in-house lawyer side by side for your scenario.

Start by measuring your workload, because it decides the answer more than anything else.

Look back over the last six to twelve months and note:

  • How many contracts were drafted, reviewed or negotiated.
  • How many employment questions came up, including hiring, terminations and foreign employees' permits.
  • How many tax, corporate or regulatory questions management had.
  • How many matters went to outside lawyers anyway, and why.
  • How many questions people did not ask because asking felt too expensive or slow.

If the result is steady work in one area, every week, an in-house role may be justified. If it is a regular flow of varied questions, with peaks and quiet months, an outsourced team with monthly hours usually fits better. If it is only a few matters a year, single-matter quotes may be enough.

Why does breadth of expertise matter for Poland–U.S. companies?

A company active in Poland and the U.S. faces two legal systems, and often questions about how they interact, which one in-house hire rarely covers.

Typical cross-border questions include:

  • Forming and running a company in each country, and how the companies relate to each other.
  • Contracts governed by Polish or U.S. law, and which law and courts to choose.
  • Tax in both countries, including cross-border structures.
  • Hiring foreigners in Poland and the work permits and residence permits they need. See hiring foreigners in Poland.
  • Moving owners, executives or staff to the U.S. on visas such as E-2 or L-1. See U.S. visas.

Each area may involve a different specialist, and coordinating several firms takes management time. A team licensed in both jurisdictions can give one coordinated answer. Totu Legal is led by Marcin Podskarbi, an attorney licensed in California and admitted to the Warsaw Bar Association, working in English and Polish from offices in Beverly Hills and Warsaw.

How do you keep continuity with each option?

Continuity depends on where the knowledge lives: in one employee's head, or in shared records your company can access.

With an in-house lawyer, continuity is strong while that person stays, and at risk when they leave, unless documents and decisions are well recorded.

With an outsourced team, continuity depends on the firm. Ask whether you will work with the same attorney, where your documents are kept and whether you can see them yourself. In our plans, matters, documents and hours used are visible in the client portal, Pro adds portal access for your HR team and permit and visa expiry alerts for foreign employees, and Enterprise adds a dedicated attorney.

Yes, and many growing companies do.

A common setup is an in-house lawyer, or an operations or HR lead, who handles daily matters in the home country, with an outside firm covering the other jurisdiction, tax, immigration and specialist work. The outside firm can also act as a sounding board for the in-house lawyer on matters outside their field.

Next step

Compare the options with your own numbers in the legal cost calculator, then see the plans and prices in your currency on the pricing page. For a larger company or group with needs across Poland and the U.S., request an enterprise proposal, or book a free legal case evaluation to talk it through with an attorney.

Frequently asked questions

When should a company hire an in-house lawyer?

Usually when there is enough steady legal work in one main area to keep a lawyer busy full-time, when the lawyer needs to sit inside daily decision-making, and when the company can also budget for outside specialists the in-house lawyer will still need.

What is an outsourced legal department?

It is an outside law firm or attorney that acts as a company's legal team on an ongoing basis, typically for a monthly fee and a set number of hours, instead of being hired for one matter at a time.

What is fractional general counsel?

A fractional general counsel is an experienced lawyer who works for your company part-time on an ongoing basis, advising management on day-to-day and strategic legal questions without being a full-time employee.

Can one lawyer cover both Polish and U.S. law?

Only if that lawyer is licensed in both jurisdictions. Totu Legal is led by an attorney licensed in California and admitted to the Warsaw Bar Association, who works in English and Polish.

Is an outsourced legal team always cheaper than in-house?

Not always. It depends on your workload. If you have enough legal work to fill a full-time role, in-house may be more economical. The legal cost calculator lets you compare both for your own scenario.

Not sure where to start? Talk to us.

Book a free 15-minute legal case evaluation with an attorney. We'll tell you whether we can help, which route fits and what it involves.

Free · 15 minutes with an attorney · Google Meet · English or Polish